Yoder’s Fresh Market (Sarasota, Florida)
Tucked into Sarasota’s Pinecraft orbit, Yoder’s Fresh Market is a compact, craveable stop for fresh produce, Amish-style jar goods, jams and jellies, and baked treats (you have to take home some whoopie-pies). Be sure to stop by the restaurant next door for some of the best fried chicken in the area, and you can’t skip the fresh rolls with apple butter. It’s an easy add-on if you’re exploring the area’s Amish heritage, and it’s open year-round!
Bristol Amish Market (Bristol, Pennsylvania)
Just outside Philadelphia, this Amish market is loved for homemade baked goods, fresh produce, and classic barn-to-table foods. Snag house-baked bread, gourmet donuts, pie slices, local cheeses, and pantry favorites that reflect Pennsylvania Dutch foodways. Grab a bag of kettlecorn, enjoy Pistol Pete’s fresh seafood, and don’t skip a tub of fresh-mad macaroni salad from the Stoltzfus Deli.
Dutch Country Farmers Market (Middletown, Delaware)
“All the pleasures of Amish country in one place” is the vibe here, with a tight mix of food merchants and shopping under one roof. Load up on produce, dairy, and deli staples, then pivot to sweets for the ride home. The market also highlights handcrafted items and furniture, so it’s a fun browse even after you’ve secured donuts. Listed as a year-round market, it runs Thursday through Saturday.
Helfing’s Amish Farm Market (Clinton Township, Michigan)
Come hungry and with a cooler. Helfing’s leans hard into naturally raised fresh meats, plus bakery, dairy, and prepared foods that make weeknight dinner feel like a holiday. The shop highlights things like oven-ready entrees and seasonal Amish-raised organic produce, along with staples such as roll butter and eggs.
Dutchman’s Store (Cantril, Iowa)
This is the kind of old-time general store where you walk in for one thing and walk out with twelve. Dutchman’s is known for bulk foods and local produce, plus kitchenwares, books, gifts, and those “how is this so useful?” finds. Pick up some freeze-dried candy, take home some delicious beef jerky, or grab a jar of homemade jam (the blackberry is perfect for toast).
Mishler’s Country Store (Dalton, Wisconsin)
If you love bulk bins and old-school practical goods, Mishler’s is a must. Travel Wisconsin spotlights a huge variety of homemadefoods and spices, produce, canned and jar goods, candy, gifts, and even old-fashioned essentials like oil lamps and herbal medicines.
Yoder’s Hometown Market (Dover, Ohio)
Think “local deli meets bulk-food paradise.” Yoder’s Hometown Market spotlights lunch meats and cheeses, fresh bread, snacks, and bulk staples, the kind of place where you can build an elite sandwich and still leave with baking supplies for later. The fresh-baked cookies are absolutely worth the trip, and you can grab meat trays for your next party as well. Did we mention they also have fry pies?
Bäckermann’s Country Market (Whiteville, Tennessee)
Bäckermann’s wears its Plain-community roots on its sleeve, describing its background in the Mennonite faith, and backing it up with the holy trinity of a great market: bakery, deli, and bulk grocery staples. You can swing by for made-on-site breads, cookies, pies, and cinnamon rolls, then pivot to sandwiches, soups, and sliced meats and cheeses. Don’t miss out on the ooey and gooey cinnamon rolls, grab a bowl of soup from the cafe or take home a piece of quality furniture made from cedar.
