No matter where you are in the U.S., there’s always a place claiming to have the best pie around—and honestly, they just might be right! Whether you’re craving a classic apple, a silky banana cream, or something totally unexpected (hello, matcha custard), nothing hits the spot quite like a perfect slice. From iconic diners to hidden gems, these pie shops are serving up flaky, buttery goodness you won’t want to miss. So grab a fork and get ready to dig in!
Hoosier Mama Pie Company (Chicago, Illinois)
With a name like Hoosier Mama, you know you’re in for some serious pie. This retro-inspired Chicago spot serves up both sweet and savory creations that feel like a delicious blast from the past. Whether you’re digging into their famous banana cream pie or keeping it classic with a slice of apple, every bite is a winner. Craving something savory? The chicken pot pie and baked potato hand pie are calling your name. Whatever you choose, you won’t regret it!
Petsi Pies (Somerville, Massachusetts)
If the locals swear by it, you know it’s the real deal. Petsi Pies has been serving up flaky, buttery goodness since 2003, and their pies keep people coming back for more. Whether you’re diving into a slice of their famous chocolate bourbon pecan or trying something different like sweet potato pecan, you’re in for a treat. Savory options like bacon, leek, and gruyere pie are just as tempting. Can’t decide? Grab a whole pie to-go and thank yourself later.
The Apple Pan (Los Angeles, California)
If you’re searching for the ultimate slice of apple pie, The Apple Pan in L.A. has you covered. Open since the 1940s, this legendary spot still rocks that old-school diner charm and serves up simple yet oh-so-perfect pies. Their famous apple pie is a must, but don’t sleep on their strawberry, coconut, or pecan options. Grab a stool at the counter, dig in, and experience a slice of L.A. history with every bite.
Four & Twenty Blackbirds (Brooklyn, New York)
In the city that never sleeps, there’s always time for pie—especially at Four & Twenty Blackbirds. Opened by two sisters in 2009, this Brooklyn favorite offers handcrafted pies in unique flavors you won’t find anywhere else. Think brown butter pumpkin, matcha custard, and their signature salty honey pie. Every slice is packed with high-quality ingredients and a whole lot of love. Trust us; you’ll be back for more.
The Village Buttery (Ruidoso, New Mexico)
Down in the Southwest, The Village Buttery is serving up pies that’ll make your taste buds dance. Their famous Buttermilk Pie has earned rave reviews, and after one bite, you’ll see why. Flaky crust, creamy filling, and just the right amount of sweetness—it’s pie perfection. Pair it with a sandwich or salad from their full menu, and don’t forget to check out their savory quiches for a delicious twist on tradition.
Kermit’s Key Lime Shop (Key West, Florida)
When it comes to key lime pie, Kermit’s is the place to be. This sunny Key West spot has been dishing out the iconic Florida treat for over 30 years, and they do it right. Go for the classic, or mix it up with variations like strawberry key lime or coconut key lime. Even better? They’ve got gluten-free options, too. Stop in, grab a slice, and soak up the island vibes—this is a key lime pie paradise.
A La Mode Pies (Seattle, Washington)
Seattle’s A La Mode Pies takes creativity to the next level with flavors that are anything but ordinary. Their Blue Hawaiian Pie—loaded with blueberry, pineapple, and coconut—is a tropical dream come true. Prefer something savory? Their pot pies and shepherd’s pie are just as drool-worthy. Whether you’re going sweet or savory, this spot proves that everything’s better a la mode.
Leoda’s Kitchen and Pie Shop (Maui, Hawaii)
Pie paradise exists, and you’ll find it at Leoda’s on Maui. This island gem serves up classic flavors like apple crumb and coconut cream, but the real showstopper is their Chocolate Mac Nut Pie. Rich, chocolatey, and packed with local macadamia nuts, it’s the ultimate island indulgence. Whether you’re grabbing a slice to-go or settling in for a meal, Leoda’s pies are worth the trip.
